60% of Property Tax Bills Are Too High — Is Yours? How to Appeal in 2026
Between 30 and 60 percent of U.S. property is overassessed, yet fewer than 5 percent of homeowners ever appeal. If your assessment exceeds comparable sale prices, challenge it: read your assessment notice for errors, build a case from comparable sales, and file before the deadline, usually 30 to 60 days after the notice arrives.
Watch the full explanation in the Problem Solved video 60% of Property Tax Bills Are Too High — Is Yours? (2026) (9 minutes 47 seconds), which walks through the appeal process, the exemptions most owners never claim, and the Chicago case where one assessment error turned an $1,800 bill into $30,000.
Key Facts
- Between 30 and 60 percent of U.S. property is overassessed, and fewer than 5 percent of homeowners ever appeal, according to the National Taxpayers Union Foundation figures cited in the video.
- Between 40 and 60 percent of property tax appeals succeed, according to the Lincoln Institute of Land Policy figures cited in the video.
- U.S. property taxes rose 26 percent between 2019 and 2023, according to the CoreLogic figures cited in the video.
- In the Chicago case cited in the video, one assessment error turned an $1,800 tax bill into $30,000.
- The video's worked example puts the saving from a successful appeal at $525 a year, and most appeal windows run only 30 to 60 days from the assessment notice.
Why So Many Bills Are Too High
Assessed value is the value your county or municipality assigns to your home for tax purposes, and it is not the same as market value, the price your home would actually fetch in a sale. An assessment notice is the official document that tells you that value, and it is the document that starts the clock on your appeal. Most assessments are produced by mass appraisal: an algorithm or a small team values thousands of homes at once, using models, recent sales, and property records, rather than inspecting your home individually.
Mass appraisal is efficient, and it is wrong in predictable ways. It can record the wrong square footage, the wrong number of bedrooms or bathrooms, a finished basement that was never finished, or a renovation that was never built. It can miss damage, a failing roof, or a neighborhood change that lowered values on your street but not on the next one. And because values are updated on a cycle, a home assessed at the peak of a local boom can carry that peak value long after sales on its own street have fallen. The result is the video's central statistic: a large share of homes carry an assessed value above their real market value, and their owners pay tax on value they do not have.
Step 1: Read Your Assessment Notice for Errors
Start with the notice itself, not with the bill. Check every fact the assessor recorded about your home: square footage, lot size, age, condition, number of rooms, and any listed improvements. A single wrong fact can explain an inflated value, and factual errors are the easiest appeals to win, because they require no argument about market trends, only a correction. Photographs, a survey, a contractor's report, or your purchase appraisal can all serve as proof.
Next, check the value against reality. Comparable sales, or comps, are the recent sale prices of homes similar to yours in size, age, condition, and location, sold within about a year, and they are the core evidence in most appeals. Your county's property records, usually searchable online, will show what comparable homes are assessed at and what they sold for. If similar homes on your street sold for materially less than your assessed value, or are assessed materially lower, you have the outline of a case. Note the deadline on the notice as you do this: in most areas you have about 30 to 60 days from the notice to file, and a strong case filed late is a lost case.
Step 2: Build the Case and File Before the Deadline
Build the case the way an assessor would want to see it: a short, documented comparison, not a complaint about taxes in general. List three to five comparable sales with addresses, sale dates, sale prices, and the key features that make them comparable to your home. Add photographs or records for any factual error, and state plainly what you believe the correct value should be and why. An appeal that attacks the tax rate, rather than the assessed value, will fail, because the appeal process decides value, not policy: if your bill is high because the rate rose, not because the value is wrong, an assessment appeal is the wrong tool.
File with the office named on the notice, keep a dated copy of everything you submit, and keep the filing receipt. Some jurisdictions decide on the papers; others schedule an informal hearing where you present the comparables in person. Either way, the discipline is the same: facts, comparables, and a number. For the fullest existing walkthrough of the same process, see our guide to fighting your home's assessment, and if you own rental property as well as your own home, our guide to rental property tax deductions covers the separate deductions that apply to landlords.
Step 3: Claim the Exemptions Most Owners Never Claim
A homestead exemption is a reduction in the taxable value of your primary residence, available in many states, usually claimed by filing a single form once, which then lowers your bill every year. It is separate from an appeal: an appeal corrects a wrong value, while an exemption removes part of the value from taxation altogether. Many owners who would win an appeal never need one, because they never claimed an exemption they were already entitled to.
Other exemptions exist in many jurisdictions for seniors, veterans, people with disabilities, and agricultural or conservation use, but the details, and the forms, vary by state and county, so check your assessor's published list rather than assuming you qualify or assuming you do not. The common thread is that exemptions are not automatic in most places: they must be claimed, and the claim is usually a form, not a fight. Checking the exemption list takes minutes, and it is the highest-return step in the whole process for owners who have never filed one.
If the County Denies Your Appeal
A denial is not the end of the process. In most jurisdictions you can appeal to a higher authority, such as a state board of tax appeals, usually within 30 to 60 days of the denial, and you can file a fresh protest the following year on new evidence. Keep the denial letter, note its deadline the day it arrives, and treat the higher appeal as a second presentation of the same documented case, strengthened by anything the first hearing revealed about the assessor's reasoning.
One fear stops many owners from filing at all, and the video answers it directly: in most states, filing an appeal cannot cause your assessment to increase, although you should confirm your own county's rules before filing. The real risk of appealing is not a higher bill; it is the time spent on a weak case. That is why the order matters: check the facts first, check the comparables second, and file only when the evidence supports a lower value. A case built on three solid comparables and one corrected fact is worth filing; a case built on the feeling that taxes are too high is not.
Who Benefits From This — and Who Does Not
Homeowners whose assessment exceeds what comparable homes actually sell for benefit most directly, because an appeal converts a documented error into a lower bill year after year. Owners who have never claimed a homestead or other exemption benefit too, often without an appeal at all, since a single form can lower the taxable value permanently. Buyers in recently reassessed neighborhoods benefit by checking the assessment before closing, and landlords benefit by treating each property's assessment and deductions separately, as our homestead exemption guide explains for the exemption side of the same saving.
This topic does not benefit renters in the same way, because the property tax bill belongs to the owner, even though rents may reflect it indirectly. It does not benefit owners whose homes are already assessed below market value, since an appeal built on comparables would confirm, not lower, their value. And it does not, on its own, help an owner whose bill rose because the tax rate rose while the assessment stayed fair: that is a policy complaint, not a valuation error, and it needs a different remedy. If your deadline has already passed, an appeal cannot help this year either, but the work is not wasted: gather the comparables now, and file first in the next cycle.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know if my property tax bill is too high?
Compare your assessed value with recent sale prices of similar homes in your area. If comparable homes sold for materially less than your assessed value, or are assessed materially lower, your bill is likely too high, and the factual details on your assessment notice may also contain an error worth correcting.
Who benefits most from appealing a property tax assessment?
Homeowners whose assessment exceeds what comparable homes actually sell for benefit most, along with owners who have never claimed a homestead or other exemption, because a successful appeal or a single exemption form can lower the bill year after year.
Who does not benefit from a property tax appeal, or for whom is it not enough?
Renters do not benefit directly, because the bill belongs to the owner. Owners already assessed below market value do not benefit, and an appeal is not enough for owners whose bill rose because the tax rate rose while the assessment stayed fair, since appeals decide value, not policy.
How do I start appealing my property tax assessment?
Read your assessment notice for factual errors, gather three to five comparable sales of similar homes sold within about a year, state the correct value and the evidence for it, claim any exemption you are entitled to, and file with the office named on the notice before the deadline printed on it, usually 30 to 60 days after the notice arrives.
Can appealing my property tax assessment make it go up?
In most states, filing an appeal cannot cause your assessment to increase, but you should confirm your own county's rules before filing, since procedures vary by jurisdiction.
What happens if the county denies my property tax appeal?
You can usually appeal to a higher authority, such as a state board of tax appeals, within 30 to 60 days of the denial, and you can file a fresh protest the following year on new evidence, so keep the denial letter and note its deadline immediately.
General information only: this article explains a property tax topic in general terms and is not tax or legal advice. Assessment rules, deadlines, and exemptions vary by state and county; always confirm the rules on your own assessment notice and with your local assessor.
For plain-language explainers on money, health, and safety topics, visit the Problem Solved channel.