Pension Overpayment Clawbacks in 2026: When Retirees Must Repay, Waivers and How to Fight Back
A pension overpayment clawback is a plan's demand that a retiree repay benefits paid in error, but since SECURE 2.0, inadvertent overpayments carry protections. A plan may choose not to seek repayment, and if it does, recovery from an annuity is capped each year, cannot push payments below 90% of the correct amount, and cannot include interest or fees.
Key Facts
- When recovery is taken from a nondecreasing annuity, the amount recovered each year cannot exceed 10% of the full overpayment.
- Future annuity payments cannot be reduced below 90% of the amount otherwise payable during recoupment.
- Recovery is barred when the first overpayment occurred more than 3 years before the participant or beneficiary first received written notice, except for fraud or misrepresentation.
- Plans cannot charge interest on an inadvertent overpayment, including during repayment, and cannot add collection costs or fees.
- Recoupment cannot be sought from a beneficiary of the participant, including a spouse, surviving spouse, or former spouse.
Why Pension Overpayments Happen
A pension overpayment means a plan paid more than the participant was entitled to receive. Causes are usually administrative: wrong service years, wrong compensation, a missed early-retirement reduction, or a survivor option applied incorrectly. The retiree rarely causes the error, yet historically bore the repayment demand.
Overpayments can run for years before an audit catches them, so the demand can be large even when the monthly error was modest. A small monthly excess over many years becomes a lump sum no retiree budget can absorb at once.
What SECURE 2.0 Changed
The SECURE 2.0 Act, effective for inadvertent overpayments from 29 December 2022, added section 206(h) to ERISA. It protects a fiduciary who chooses not to seek repayment of an inadvertent overpayment, removing the old fear that waiving recovery would itself be a breach. A plan may still pursue recovery, but must then respect the protections below.
The relief is limited. It does not excuse a plan from protecting other participants if waiving recovery would materially affect a defined benefit plan's ability to pay benefits, and it does not protect a fiduciary whose own breach caused the overpayment.
The Limits on Recoupment
When a plan recoups from a nondecreasing annuity by reducing future payments, three limits apply: annual recovery cannot exceed 10% of the full overpayment, the monthly payment cannot fall below 90% of the amount otherwise payable, and the reduction must end when the overpayment is fully recovered. The plan cannot charge interest or fees, use a collection agency or prohibited threats, or seek the money from a beneficiary.
A separate three-year rule bars recovery when the first overpayment occurred more than three years before written notice of the error, except for fraud or misrepresentation. For lump sums and other non-annuity payments, recovery follows Labor Department rules, so retirees should ask which category their payment falls into. Retirees weighing a 401(k) loan against a hardship withdrawal face a different set of tax rules and should not confuse those choices with a pension clawback.
How to Fight Back, Step by Step
Start by demanding the calculation, not by paying. Ask for the service record, compensation figures, plan formula, and the date of each overpaid month, then check the arithmetic. Next, test the three-year rule and the 10% and 90% limits against the plan's proposal, and put any hardship in writing.
If the plan will not waive recovery, ask for a smaller reduction or a longer repayment period, and use the plan's formal claims procedure to appeal within its deadline. Keep every letter. For a plain-language video explainer, visit the Problem Solved channel.
Who Benefits From This — and Who Does Not
Who benefits:
A retiree hit by a long-running error benefits because the three-year rule and annual caps may wipe out or sharply shrink a demand that once arrived as a single lump sum.
A fixed-income retiree benefits because the 90% floor protects the monthly budget, and hardship can reduce or waive recovery.
A retiree requesting a waiver benefits because fiduciaries are now protected when they waive an inadvertent overpayment, making a documented waiver request worthwhile.
Who does not benefit:
A participant who misrepresented facts to the plan does not benefit, because fraud or misrepresentation removes the three-year protection and the other safeguards for inadvertent overpayments.
A lump-sum recipient may not benefit the same way, because non-annuity overpayments follow separate Labor Department rules.
A retiree who ignores the plan's deadlines does not benefit in practice, because appeal rights under a plan's claims procedure are time-limited and a missed deadline can close off a strong argument.
Workers worried about a failed employer plan should read how the PBGC pension guarantee works when a company fails.
This article is general information, not legal or financial advice.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who benefits from the SECURE 2.0 overpayment protections?
Retirees who received an inadvertent overpayment from an employer plan benefit most, because the plan may now choose not to seek repayment, and any recoupment is capped, cannot include interest or fees, and cannot be taken from a spouse or beneficiary.
Who does not benefit, or who is not eligible for these protections?
Participants whose overpayment involved fraud or misrepresentation do not benefit from the same protections, and the three-year limit does not protect them. Workers in plans outside ERISA, such as some government plans, follow different rules and should not assume SECURE 2.0 applies.
How do I benefit, and how do I start fighting a clawback?
First, ask the plan in writing for the full calculation and the exact months involved. Second, check whether the first overpayment occurred more than three years before written notice. Third, ask whether the plan will waive recovery or accept a smaller reduction, citing hardship if it applies. Fourth, use the plan's claims procedure before any deadline.
Can a plan charge interest or collection fees on an overpayment?
No. Under SECURE 2.0 for inadvertent overpayments, the plan cannot charge interest, including during repayment, and cannot add collection costs or fees. If a demand includes them, ask the plan to remove them.
Can a plan reduce my future pension payments to recover an overpayment?
Yes, but only within limits for a nondecreasing annuity: annual recovery cannot exceed 10% of the full overpayment, payments cannot fall below 90% of the amount otherwise payable, and the reduction must stop once fully recovered.