Skip Part D and Pay $9.40 a Month Forever: the Penalty That Never Ends — Before December 7
Skipping Medicare Part D for two years without other drug coverage adds a permanent surcharge of about $9.40 to your monthly premium — 1% of the national base premium for each uncovered month, charged for as long as you have Part D. December 7 is the deadline to lock in 2027 coverage and stop the clock.
Watch the video this article is based on: Skip Medicare Part D? The $9.40 Penalty That NEVER Ends (about 2 minutes and 30 seconds, published October 22, 2026) — it explains the 1%-a-month formula and why December 7 is the deadline that stops it.
- The Part D late enrollment penalty is 1% of the national base beneficiary premium for each full month without creditable drug coverage.
- The 2026 national base beneficiary premium is $38.99 — so 12 uncovered months cost about $4.70 a month, and 24 months about $9.40.
- The trigger is 63 or more days without creditable coverage after your enrollment window ends.
- The penalty is permanent: it follows you from plan to plan, and switching plans never erases it.
- December 7 locks your Medicare choices for 2027 — the last chance to enrol or switch before the new year.
A Penalty With No Expiry Date
Most penalties in life have an end. This one does not. Medicare Part D is the prescription-drug part of Medicare, and if you go without Part D or other creditable drug coverage for long enough, Medicare adds a late enrollment penalty to your Part D premium — and keeps adding it for as long as you have Part D coverage, whether that is one year or twenty.
Creditable coverage is drug coverage that is at least as good as standard Part D — typically from an employer plan, VA, TRICARE, or Medicaid. The distinction matters because the penalty is not about whether you took medicine; it is about whether you were covered. A healthy person who takes no prescriptions but also holds no drug coverage is still accumulating uncovered months, and the clock does not care how well you feel.
The $9.40 Math, Step by Step
The formula is short enough to check by hand. The penalty equals 1% of the national base beneficiary premium — a figure Medicare sets each year, $38.99 for 2026 — multiplied by the number of full months you went without creditable coverage. Twelve uncovered months gives 12 times 1% times $38.99, which is $4.68, rounded to the nearest $0.10 to $4.70 a month. Twenty-four months gives $9.36, rounded to $9.40 a month. Thirty-six months gives $14.04, rounded to $14.00 a month.
Two features of that arithmetic deserve attention. First, the rounding is to the nearest ten cents, which is why the figures land on $4.70 and $9.40 rather than $4.68 and $9.36. Second, the dollar amount is not frozen: the base premium is recalculated every year, so a penalty built on the 2026 base can grow as future bases rise. A $9.40 surcharge today is a floor, not a ceiling — and because it is charged every month for life, even a small monthly figure compounds into thousands of dollars over a retirement.
Why Feeling Healthy Does Not Stop the Clock
The most common way into this penalty is also the most understandable: you feel fine, you take no regular prescriptions, and drug coverage looks like money spent on nothing. The problem is the trigger. Once your initial enrollment window ends, 63 or more days without creditable coverage is enough to start the penalty — and every further full month adds another 1%. The gap does not need to be dramatic. A year spent assuming you will enrol later, followed by another year of the same assumption, is exactly how a $9.40 surcharge is built.
December 7 is the date that turns an open-ended drift into a closed door. Medicare's annual enrollment period ends on December 7, and the choices made by then lock in your coverage for the following year. Miss it, and the uncovered months keep accumulating until the next enrollment window — with the penalty growing all the while. Feeling healthy does not pause that calendar.
The Exceptions That Save You — If You Can Prove Them
Not every gap counts. Time covered by creditable employer, VA, TRICARE, or Medicaid drug coverage does not generate a penalty, and neither does time spent receiving Extra Help, the program that helps people with limited income pay Part D costs. These exceptions are generous — but they are not automatic. You must be able to document the coverage, which means keeping the letters that prove it.
That documentation point is the practical heart of this article. If you had employer drug coverage, get the creditable-coverage letter from that employer or plan and keep it somewhere you can find it years later. If you had VA or TRICARE coverage, keep the proof of that too. When Medicare later asks whether a gap was covered, the answer that counts is the one you can show, not the one you remember. People who lose the letter can end up paying a penalty for months that should never have counted.
What to Do Before December 7
The checklist is short and the deadline is fixed. First, compare Part D plans for 2027 now — not on December 6, when the comparison will be rushed and the enrollment system busy. Second, check that your prescriptions are covered and that your pharmacy is in the plan's network, because drug lists and networks change quietly from year to year. Third, gather your creditable-coverage letters before you need them, especially if you are newly enrolling after employer coverage ended.
Fourth, if you are unsure whether your current coverage counts as creditable, ask the plan or employer directly and get the answer in writing — a verbal assurance helps no one at penalty-review time. And fifth, if cost is the reason you skipped Part D, check Extra Help eligibility before assuming the penalty is unavoidable: the program exists precisely for people who would otherwise go uncovered. For the broader penalty landscape, including Part B, see our guide to Medicare late enrollment penalties, and for the drug-cost side of the same decision, our guide to spreading the Part D bill across the year.
Who Benefits From This — and Who Does Not
People approaching Medicare eligibility without drug coverage benefit most — they are the ones who can still avoid the penalty entirely by enrolling on time. People who skipped Part D in the past and are still uncovered benefit next: every month they wait adds another 1%, so acting before December 7 stops the growth even though it cannot erase the months already accumulated. And people leaving employer coverage benefit from checking, before the coverage ends, that their next step keeps them continuously covered.
People who have held creditable coverage continuously do not need this article's warning — no gap, no penalty, and nothing to fix. People already enrolled in Part D are likewise unaffected, though the drug-cost picture still matters to them: our guide to the Part D out-of-pocket cap covers what their coverage actually pays. And Extra Help recipients are protected from the penalty by the program itself — for them, the priority is keeping that eligibility documented, not fearing a surcharge.
Frequently Asked Questions
How is the Part D late enrollment penalty calculated?
Multiply 1% of the national base beneficiary premium — $38.99 in 2026 — by the number of full months you went without creditable drug coverage, rounded to the nearest $0.10. Twelve months gives about $4.70 a month; 24 months gives about $9.40.
Does the Part D penalty ever go away?
No. It is permanent for as long as you have Part D coverage, it follows you from plan to plan, and switching plans never erases it. The dollar amount can also grow as the base premium is recalculated each year.
What counts as creditable drug coverage?
Drug coverage at least as good as standard Part D — typically from an employer plan, VA, TRICARE, or Medicaid — plus time receiving Extra Help. Keep the coverage letters that prove it; Medicare counts the coverage you can document.
Who benefits most from acting before December 7?
People newly eligible for Medicare without drug coverage, who can still avoid the penalty entirely, and people already uncovered, for whom every further month adds another 1% — acting now stops the growth even though past months cannot be erased.
Who does not need to worry about this penalty?
People who have held creditable coverage continuously, people already enrolled in Part D, and Extra Help recipients, who are protected by the program. For them, the drug-cost cap and plan details matter more than the penalty.
How do I check and stop the penalty before December 7?
Compare Part D plans for 2027, confirm your prescriptions and pharmacy are covered, and gather creditable-coverage letters from any employer or VA/TRICARE plan. If you are unsure your coverage counts, ask in writing. Confirm the current rules at Medicare.gov or with a licensed counselor before enrolling.
For more plain-English breakdowns of everyday money traps, see the Problem Solved channel: Problem Solved.
General information only, not insurance or financial advice. Medicare rules and premium figures change annually — confirm the current base premium and your coverage status at Medicare.gov or with a licensed counselor before acting.