Medicare Advantage vs Medigap in 2026: Costs, Networks and Which Fits You
At 65, Medicare gives you a real choice: a Medicare Advantage plan with a modest monthly premium and a yearly cap on out-of-pocket costs, or Original Medicare plus a Medigap policy that absorbs nearly all deductibles and coinsurance for a higher premium. Which fits in 2026 comes down to your health, your doctors, and your budget.
Watch the explainer on our channel: Problem Solved on YouTube.
What Medicare Advantage covers
Medicare Advantage — also called Part C — is Medicare delivered through a private insurer under federal contract. Every plan must cover everything Original Medicare covers: hospital care under Part A plus doctor and outpatient services under Part B. Beyond that, plans typically bundle drug coverage and extras such as dental, vision, and hearing.
The trade-off is structure. Most plans operate as HMOs or PPOs — provider networks of contracted doctors and hospitals. You generally pay less in network, and HMO plans usually require a referral before specialist visits. Networks are built county by county, so plan quality depends heavily on where you live.
Every plan also sets a yearly maximum out-of-pocket (MOOP) limit on covered medical services — unlike Original Medicare, which has no ceiling. CMS sets a regulatory ceiling on that maximum each year, and each plan publishes its own number.
What Medigap adds to Original Medicare
Medigap — formally Medicare Supplement Insurance — fills the gaps in Original Medicare. You keep your Medicare card and see any Medicare-accepting doctor or hospital nationwide — no networks, no referrals. When Medicare pays its share, the policy pays most or all of the remainder: the Part B deductible, the 20 percent outpatient coinsurance, and hospital coinsurance.
Benefits are standardized into lettered plans. Plan G — the most popular choice for new enrollees — covers everything Original Medicare leaves behind except the annual Part B deductible; after paying it, Medicare-approved care is generally covered in full for the rest of the year.
Every insurer sells the same standardized Plan G, so companies differ only in premium and service. You cannot pair Medigap with Medicare Advantage — the two paths are mutually exclusive by federal rule — and Medigap excludes prescription drugs, so this path needs a separate stand-alone Part D plan. If you are still working at 65, our individual vs group disability insurance comparison is a useful companion read on employer benefits.
Comparing monthly costs side by side
Everyone on Medicare pays the standard Part B premium of $202.90 per month. On the Medicare Advantage path, you add the plan premium — CMS estimates the national average at $14.00 per month in 2026 — for a typical fixed monthly cost of $216.90, before copays for care you use.
On the Medigap path, the same $202.90 is joined by Plan G averaging about $164/month (analysis cited by Mercer Advisors) plus a stand-alone Part D plan averaging $34.50 — $401.40 in monthly premiums — plus the $283 annual Part B deductible.
Medigap costs more to carry but absorbs nearly all cost-sharing after the $283 deductible; Advantage is cheaper to carry, but a serious illness can push your cost-sharing to the plan’s annual maximum. Which wins depends on how much care you use — unknowable at 65. The Part B premium follows you on either path; our 2027 Part B premium projection explains how the cost-of-living adjustment softens its rise.
Key facts
- Average Medicare Advantage monthly premium: $14.00 in 2026, down from $16.40 in 2025 (CMS, September 26, reported by the American Hospital Association).
- 98 percent of beneficiaries can access a drug-covering Advantage plan charging no premium beyond Part B; 67 percent of such plans charge no additional premium (KFF, 2026 Spotlight).
- The standard Medicare Part B premium is $202.90 per month in 2026 (KFF, 2026 Spotlight).
- Medigap Plan G averages about $164/month in 2026; all-plan average roughly $217 (analysis cited by Mercer Advisors); Part B deductible $283 (CoverRight).
- Advantage plans cap in-network spending within a CMS-regulated ceiling; projected 2026 enrollment about 34 million (CMS; American Hospital Association).
Networks, referrals and travel
Medicare Advantage networks are local: if your specialist or hospital is out of network, you switch doctors or pay significantly more. HMO plans typically require referrals; PPO plans let you go out of network at a higher price.
If you travel often or split the year between states, Original Medicare with Medigap lets you see any Medicare-accepting provider anywhere in the country. Note Medicare generally does not cover care abroad — see our guide on when travel insurance is worth it.
Who each option tends to suit
Medicare Advantage often suits the relatively healthy who accept a local network and want the lowest monthly premium — many pay no premium beyond Part B. The built-in cost cap defines a worst case many retirees find comforting.
Medigap suits those who want provider freedom, travel widely, or prefer a higher fixed premium for near-zero surprise bills — especially those with known conditions who expect heavy specialist or hospital use.
Mind the timing: your six-month Medigap open enrollment begins with Part B enrollment at 65, and during it insurers cannot use medical underwriting. Afterward, most states allow insurers to ask health questions and charge more or decline you. You can switch from Advantage to Medigap later — e.g. during the January 1 to March 31 open enrollment — but the underwriting risk is real.
Who Benefits From This — and Who Does Not
There is no universally cheaper path at 65 — Advantage wins on monthly premium, Medigap wins on predictability, and your health, doctors, and travel decide which matters more.
Who benefits
- Healthy beneficiaries who want low fixed costs: On the Advantage path, the $202.90 Part B premium plus a national average plan premium of $14.00 a month gives a typical fixed monthly cost of $216.90, before copays — and 98 percent of beneficiaries can access a drug-covering Advantage plan charging no premium beyond Part B.
- Travellers and people who split the year between states: Original Medicare with Medigap lets you see any Medicare-accepting doctor or hospital nationwide — no networks, no referrals — while Advantage networks are built county by county.
- People who want costs capped after one deductible: With Medigap Plan G — averaging about $164 a month plus a stand-alone Part D plan averaging $34.50, or $401.40 in monthly premiums plus the $283 annual Part B deductible — Medicare-approved care is generally covered in full for the rest of the year after the deductible.
Who does not benefit
- Anyone who wants both Advantage and Medigap: You cannot pair them — the two paths are mutually exclusive by federal rule — and Medigap excludes prescription drugs, so that path needs a separate stand-alone Part D plan.
- People whose doctors sit outside an Advantage network: If your specialist or hospital is out of network, you switch doctors or pay significantly more, and HMO plans usually require a referral before specialist visits.
- Beneficiaries who pick on premium alone: Advantage is cheaper to carry, but a serious illness can push cost-sharing to the plan’s annual maximum — which wins depends on how much care you use, which is unknowable at 65.
One gap neither path closes is care abroad — Medicare generally does not cover it — so see our guide on when travel insurance is worth it before travelling outside the United States.
Frequently asked questions
Can I have both Medicare Advantage and Medigap?
No. Federal rules bar insurers from selling Medigap while you are in Medicare Advantage — choose one path, though you can switch during enrollment windows.
Can I switch from Medicare Advantage to Medigap later?
Yes — during the January 1 to March 31 Advantage open enrollment or the fall annual enrollment, you can return to Original Medicare and apply for Medigap. But after your initial six-month open enrollment, most states allow medical underwriting: higher premiums or a declined application.
Do Medicare Advantage plans include dental, vision, and hearing?
Most do. CMS reports supplemental benefits remain stable for 2026, and KFF finds about 89 percent of individual-enrollment plans include drug coverage, with dental, vision, and hearing widely offered. Allowances vary by plan and county.
Does Medigap cover prescription drugs?
No. Medigap policies sold today do not include drug coverage. If you choose Original Medicare with Medigap, you need a separate stand-alone Part D plan for your prescriptions.
Who benefits from Medicare Advantage, and who benefits from Medigap?
Medicare Advantage benefits healthy beneficiaries who want low fixed costs: the $202.90 Part B premium plus a national average plan premium of $14.00 a month gives a typical fixed monthly cost of $216.90, and 98 percent of beneficiaries can access a drug-covering Advantage plan charging no premium beyond Part B. Medigap benefits travellers and people who split the year between states, since Original Medicare with Medigap lets you see any Medicare-accepting provider nationwide with no networks or referrals, and people who want costs capped after one deductible — Plan G averages about $164 a month plus a Part D plan averaging $34.50. Neither path benefits someone who wants both, since the two are mutually exclusive by federal rule, or someone whose doctors sit outside an Advantage network. The full breakdown is in the section “Who Benefits From This — and Who Does Not” above.
How do I start choosing between Advantage and Medigap?
First, list your doctors and hospitals and check whether each sits inside the Advantage plans available in your county — networks are built county by county, so plan quality depends heavily on where you live. Second, compare fixed costs: about $216.90 a month on the Advantage path versus about $401.40 a month plus the $283 annual Part B deductible on the Medigap Plan G path, remembering that Advantage copays can rise to the plan’s annual maximum in a serious illness year. Third, weigh travel: if you travel often or split the year between states, the nationwide access of Original Medicare with Medigap usually outweighs Advantage’s lower premium.
Disclaimer: This article is general information only and is not legal or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.