Hernia Mesh Recalls 2026: the Full Recall List — and What to Do If Yours Is on It

Several hernia mesh products have been recalled or withdrawn: Ethicon withdrew Physiomesh in 2016, Atrium recalled 145,000+ C-QUR units in 2013, Bard recalled Composix Kugel patches over ring-breakage risks, and Ethicon recalled 18,000+ Proceed units. If your mesh is affected, confirm your operative report, see your surgeon about symptoms, and preserve your records.

Prefer to watch? See our explainer on Problem Solved's YouTube channel.

Hernia mesh recalls unfolded over two decades — product by product, lot by lot — some announced by manufacturers, some graded by the FDA, one technically not a recall at all. Below: the confirmed list, what each action means, and what to do if your mesh appears on it.

Recall vs. market withdrawal: why the wording matters

The FDA distinguishes a recall — removal of a legally violative product — from a market withdrawal, a company pull over a minor violation or business decision. Recalls are graded: Class I (probable serious harm or death), Class II (temporary or reversible harm — the most common for hernia mesh), Class III (unlikely to cause harm). The FDA rarely forces recalls, so the record is built from voluntary notices — which is why one product is described differently in different places.

The confirmed recall list

These are named, documented actions confirmed through FDA records or manufacturer notices — not rumor.

Bard Composix Kugel patches (2006). The memory recoil ring could break, risking bowel perforation or enteric fistula — tens of thousands of patches covered.

Atrium C-QUR mesh (2013). 145,000+ units recalled (Class II): humidity made the omega-3 coating stick to the package liner, damaging the coating on removal.

Ethicon Proceed mesh (2005–2014). 18,000+ units recalled (Class II): packaging defects could cause layer separation ("delamination").

Atrium ProLite (Nov 2017). Wrong mesh configuration packaged under incorrect codes and lots — providers told to quarantine and return.

Repackaged Physiomesh, EXP (2015). Two sizes recalled over the repackager's missing registration and quality controls — a repackaging action, not a design one.

Covidien Parietex Composite (specific lot). Collagen film applied to the wrong side — a manufacturing error.

Gentrix Surgical Matrix, ACell (2019). Two products recalled for failing tensile strength specifications.

  • Class II is the most common grade for hernia mesh recalls — temporary or medically reversible harm, not life-threatening defect.
  • 145,000+ units of Atrium C-QUR mesh were recalled in 2013 after humidity made the coating stick to the package liner.
  • 18,000+ units of Ethicon Proceed mesh were recalled between 2005 and 2014 over packaging defects that could cause layer separation.
  • 2016 is when Ethicon withdrew Physiomesh after registry data showed higher hernia recurrence and reoperation rates — a withdrawal, not a formal U.S. recall.
  • 25,896 hernia mesh lawsuits were pending across four federal multidistrict litigations as of September 2026.

Physiomesh: the withdrawal that behaves like a recall

Ethicon's Physiomesh for laparoscopic use confuses almost everyone. After registry data showed higher recurrence and reoperation rates, Ethicon issued a 2016 U.S. market withdrawal — but formal recalls in Australia and Europe. Legally a withdrawal, practically a pull over performance. If you received Physiomesh before 2016, the label is academic — what matters is whether your product matches the one withdrawn.

How to find out which mesh you have

Everything turns on identification: manufacturer, product, model, lot number. Request your operative report from the hospital's medical-records department — its implant log lists all four. Ask your surgeon too: practices often keep the peel-off product sticker from the packaging. Match the product (and lot, for lot-level recalls) against the list above and keep copies. For what happens when recalled mesh causes complications, see our guide to hernia mesh lawsuits, verdicts, and who qualifies.

What to do if your mesh is affected

Do not assume it must come out. Explant surgery carries its own risks, and many patients with recalled mesh have no symptoms — removal is a surgical judgment based on symptoms and imaging, not a notice. See your surgeon about symptoms: chronic pain, a bulge suggesting recurrence, infection signs, or bowel changes; bring your operative report. Document everything: a dated symptom log, visits, imaging, costs. Understand the legal picture: MDL — multidistrict litigation — consolidates similar federal cases before one judge; hernia mesh cases have proceeded through several MDLs, and a recall strengthens product identification. Deadlines vary by state and run from discovery of injury, not the recall date — see our hernia mesh lawsuit qualification guide.

Who Benefits From This — and Who Does Not

Who benefits from this recall list:

People who had hernia surgery with a named product on the list. How to use it: Request your operative report and implant log from the hospital's medical-records department — they list manufacturer, product, model, and lot number — and match them against the list, including lot numbers for lot-level recalls.

People with symptoms after a mesh repair. How to use it: See your surgeon with your operative report about chronic pain, a bulge suggesting recurrence, infection signs, or bowel changes, and keep a dated symptom log with visits, imaging, and costs.

People weighing legal action after a mesh complication. How to use it: A recall strengthens product identification, and deadlines generally run from when you discovered or should have discovered the injury — not from the recall date — so speak with a qualified attorney promptly, since some states allow only a year or two.

Who does not benefit:

Anyone expecting a recall notice to mean the mesh must come out. Why: Removal is a surgical judgment based on symptoms and imaging, not on a notice — removal surgery carries its own risks, and many people with recalled mesh have no symptoms.

Anyone assuming the Physiomesh label settles the question. Why: In the U.S. it was a 2016 market withdrawal, with formal recalls in Australia and Europe — what matters for you is whether your product matches the one withdrawn, not the label.

Anyone waiting to act because the recall date feels recent. Why: Your deadline runs from discovery of the injury, so waiting can cost you the claim even while the recall list stays public.

For what happens when recalled mesh causes complications, see: Hernia Mesh Lawsuits 2026: Verdicts, and Who Qualifies.

FAQ

Was Ethicon Physiomesh recalled?

In the U.S., Ethicon issued a 2016 market withdrawal of Physiomesh for laparoscopic use after registry data showed higher recurrence and reoperation rates — technically a withdrawal, not a formal FDA recall; formal recalls were issued in Australia and Europe. For patients, the practical effect is the same: the product was pulled over performance concerns.

Does a recall mean my mesh has to be removed?

No. A recall identifies a product problem; it does not prescribe your treatment. Many people with recalled mesh have no symptoms. Removal surgery has its own risks and is decided with a surgeon based on symptoms, imaging, and overall health — not on the notice alone.

How do I get my operative report years later?

Contact the hospital or surgical center's medical-records department and request the operative report and implant log, which list manufacturer, product, size, and lot number. Hospitals retain these records long-term, and your surgeon's practice may hold the product sticker from the packaging.

How long do I have to take legal action?

Statutes of limitation vary by state and generally run from when you discovered or should have discovered the injury — not from the recall date. Some states allow only a year or two, so speak with a qualified attorney promptly rather than assuming you have time.

What is an MDL?

Multidistrict litigation consolidates thousands of similar federal cases before one judge for coordinated pretrial work — shared discovery and bellwether test trials. You keep your own case and damages; the MDL just makes the shared work efficient.

Who benefits from this hernia mesh recall list — and who should not rely on it alone?

People who had surgery with a named product benefit most, because matching the operative report — manufacturer, product, model, and lot — against the list turns a vague worry into a concrete answer, and people with symptoms benefit by taking that report to their surgeon with a dated symptom log. It does not help anyone who expects a recall notice alone to decide treatment — removal is a surgical judgment, not a notice — or anyone who waits, since legal deadlines run from discovery of the injury, not from the recall date. First step: Request your operative report and implant log, match your product and lot against the list, and see your surgeon about any symptoms.

This article provides general information only and is not legal, financial, or tax advice. Rules and limits change over time, and individual circumstances vary — consult a qualified professional before acting on anything you read here.

Watch on YouTube

Problem Solved on YouTube