Can't Finish Your Chapter 13 Plan in 2026? The Hardship Discharge, the 3 Tests, and What Debts Survive It
If illness, job loss, or another event outside your control stops you from finishing a Chapter 13 plan, you may not have to start over or lose the case. A hardship discharge under section 1328(b) of the Bankruptcy Code can end the case early — but only if you pass three strict tests and ask the court for it.
- Key fact: The rule is 11 U.S.C. § 1328(b): a court may grant a discharge even though the plan was never completed.
- Key fact: All three statutory tests must pass — a qualifying cause, the liquidation comparison, and no workable modification.
- Key fact: Unsecured creditors must receive at least what they would have received if your assets had been liquidated under Chapter 7.
- Key fact: A hardship discharge is narrower than a completion discharge: support obligations, most student loans, fraud debts, and long-term mortgage debts survive it.
- Key fact: Nothing is automatic. You must file a motion, present evidence, and win a hearing.
What a Hardship Discharge Actually Is
Chapter 13 is the repayment chapter of bankruptcy: a person with regular income proposes a plan, approved by the court, to repay creditors over three to five years, and a discharge at the end wipes out the remaining eligible debts. A hardship discharge is the exception for the debtor whose plan breaks down through no fault of their own. In plain terms, it is an early discharge: the court closes the case and discharges the debts that a hardship discharge can reach, even though the plan was never finished. It is not a reward for giving up, and it is not available simply because payments became uncomfortable. The statute reserves it for the debtor who genuinely cannot finish, and the burden of proving that sits entirely on the debtor.
The Three Tests the Court Applies
The court applies three tests, and failing any one of them ends the request. First, the failure to complete the plan must be due to circumstances for which the debtor should not justly be held accountable. Courts commonly look for events like a serious illness or disability, an employer closing, or the loss of a contributing household income — events the debtor did not cause and could not reasonably have prevented. A voluntary decision to stop paying, or a spending choice that drained the plan payment, does not meet this test. Second, the value already distributed to unsecured creditors must be at least what those creditors would have received if the debtor's nonexempt property had been sold in a Chapter 7 liquidation. Third, modification of the plan must not be practicable — meaning no realistic revised plan, such as lower payments or a longer schedule within the legal limits, could still work. Consider a worked example, framed only as an illustration: a plan of $300 a month for 60 months totals $18,000; after 36 months the debtor has paid $10,800; a disabling illness then ends all income. If the Chapter 7 liquidation value of the debtor's nonexempt property is $4,000, the $10,800 already paid clears the second test, and the case turns on the first and third tests. The arithmetic is simple; the evidence is what decides the motion.
What Debts Survive a Hardship Discharge
This is the part that surprises most debtors, and it must be understood before filing the motion. Section 1328(c) provides that a hardship discharge does not discharge two groups of debts. The first group is debts that section 523(a) excepts from discharge, which include domestic support obligations, most student loans, debts incurred through fraud, certain tax debts, and debts for willful and malicious injury. The second group is long-term debts provided for under section 1322(b)(5) — typically a home mortgage that the plan cured and maintained, which continues after the case on its original terms. In practical terms, a hardship discharge can clear credit cards, medical bills, and personal loans that the plan was paying, but it will not erase child support arrears, will not erase a student loan, and will not remove the mortgage itself. Anyone whose main goal is one of those surviving debts needs a different strategy, not this motion.
Hardship Discharge vs. Your Other Three Options
A hardship discharge is one of four exits when a plan falters, and choosing wrong wastes months. Modification under section 1329 lets the court change the plan — lower payments, extend the schedule within the legal maximum, or adjust for changed income — and if any workable modification exists, the hardship discharge fails its third test, so modification must be considered first. Conversion to Chapter 7 liquidates nonexempt property and discharges eligible debts, which may suit a debtor with little property but costs the home protections Chapter 13 was preserving. Dismissal ends the case with no discharge at all: creditors resume collection, and if you refile within a year of a dismissal, the automatic stay — the court order that stops collection — may last only 30 days unless the court extends it. A hardship discharge sits between these: it keeps the case's protection, ends it early, and discharges what it can, which is why courts test it so strictly.
The 5 Steps to Ask for It
First, tell your attorney and the trustee immediately, in writing, the moment you know payments cannot continue — silence is what turns hardship into dismissal. Second, gather proof of the cause: medical records and a doctor's statement for illness, a termination letter for job loss, or business closure records for self-employment collapse. Third, run the liquidation comparison with your attorney: list nonexempt property, estimate its Chapter 7 value, and compare it with what unsecured creditors have already received. Fourth, file a motion for hardship discharge that states each of the three tests and attaches the evidence; creditors and the trustee may object, and the court will set a hearing. Fifth, attend the hearing prepared to explain, honestly and briefly, what changed, what you paid, and why no modified plan could work. Throughout, keep paying what you can, and never stop paying a mortgage or support obligation on the assumption that the motion covers them — it does not.
The Mistake That Turns Hardship Into Dismissal
The costliest mistake is also the most human: going quiet. A debtor who misses payments without explanation invites the trustee to move for dismissal, and a dismissed case leaves the debtor with no discharge, resumed collection, and a harder refiling road. The second mistake is hiding changed circumstances — new income, a new job, or a recovered ability to pay — which destroys credibility at the hearing and can defeat the motion outright. The third is waiting until the plan has already collapsed to seek help: the motion takes time to prepare, creditors need notice, and a hearing must be scheduled, so the request should be made while the case is still alive and the payment record still shows good faith. If you remember one sentence from this article, let it be this: tell the court early, in writing, with proof.
Who Benefits From This — and Who Does Not
A worker who became disabled midway through a plan benefits directly: the cause is documented, the payments already made are real, and no reduced payment can come from income that no longer exists. A household that lost its second income when a contributing spouse lost work benefits for the same reason, provided the numbers show that no modified plan could work. A debtor near the end of a plan, struck by a medical crisis in the final year, also benefits, because the liquidation comparison is usually already satisfied by years of payments. If you have already missed payments, read what to do when a Chapter 13 payment is missed before the trustee acts. Who does not benefit? A debtor who simply stopped paying without a qualifying cause fails the first test immediately. A debtor who could still complete a reduced plan fails the third test, because modification is practicable. And a debtor whose real goal is erasing support arrears, student loans, or a mortgage fails on the substance, because those debts survive a hardship discharge — for those debts, how a Chapter 13 plan treats a home and a car explains what the plan itself can and cannot do.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who benefits most from a hardship discharge?
Debtors whose income ended through illness, disability, or job loss they did not cause, and who have already paid unsecured creditors at least the Chapter 7 liquidation value, benefit most, because they can satisfy all three statutory tests.
Who does not qualify for a hardship discharge?
Debtors who stopped paying voluntarily, who could still finish a modified plan, or whose main debts are support obligations, student loans, or long-term mortgages do not qualify, because they fail a statutory test or seek to discharge debts the statute leaves behind.
How do I start a hardship discharge request?
First, notify your attorney and the trustee in writing that payments cannot continue and why. Second, collect proof of the cause, such as medical records or a termination letter. Third, compare what unsecured creditors already received with the Chapter 7 liquidation value. Fourth, file a motion for hardship discharge with that evidence and attend the hearing.
Does a hardship discharge wipe out my mortgage?
No. A long-term mortgage provided for under section 1322(b)(5) survives a hardship discharge and continues on its original terms, so you must keep paying it to keep the home.
What happens if the court denies my hardship discharge?
The case continues, and you must choose among the other options: modify the plan under section 1329, convert to Chapter 7, or face dismissal if payments cannot resume.
Can I refile if my case is dismissed instead?
Refiling is often possible, but it is harder: if you refile within a year of a dismissal, the automatic stay may last only 30 days unless the court extends it, and in some dismissal situations the Code bars refiling for 180 days, so get advice before letting a case be dismissed.
This article is general information about bankruptcy law, not legal advice for your situation. Bankruptcy rules turn on individual facts, so speak with a licensed bankruptcy attorney before filing any motion.
For more plain-English guides to money and the law, visit the Problem Solved channel: Problem Solved on YouTube.